Exfat Vs Ntfs Tuxera For Mac Windows Drives
Last year, out of necessity to figure out which tool to use, I posted a comparison of Tuxera and Paragon NTFS drivers on macOS Sierra. I just bought a shiny new too-expensive-and-questionably-fit-for-sale MacBook Pro 2018, and the question is newly prescient. Some things have changed – we’re on High Sierra looking to Mojave now, both drivers have new versions out, and this new machine now has not only USB 3.1 Gen2, but more generally, 160GBit/s I/O that could fully saturate virtually any storage device you could plug into it. That almost includes some hypothetical external RAMdisk. Part of my plan for this machine going forward is to start running space-intense tasks like VMs and my photo library from an external NVMe SSD that can actually utilize that silly bandwidth, and may itself be shared with Windows 10 machines, so here we are.
NTFS-formatted hard drives are read-only when plugged into a Mac. To write to NTFS formatted drive, the easiest way is to install a NTFS for Mac software.Among them, Tuxera NTFS for Mac, NTFS-3G and Paragon NTFS for Mac are widely used by Mac users. Nov 22, 2013 When using a external hard drive formatted with ntfs file system on a mac computer, you will note that its just possible to read the data on it, meaning, its not possible to transfer data from. Virtual dj 8 download for windows 10.
What’s the same?
Licensing (kind of). Paragon still charges $20 for their NTFS driver, licensed per-machine with no upgrades. Tuxera still charges $31 for thiers, on a per-user basis with free upgrades to new versions. Winner: Tuxera. Except, there are some extenuating circumstances at the moment: Tuxera’s currently on sale for $18, and Paragon has released a package suite of drivers which includes free upgrades, and is $50. These factors make things a little less straightforward, but still I feel sum up in Tuxera’s favor. (UPDATE: Originally, I thought the package suite was on SALE for $50, but I think that’s actually the normal price and $100 is what you’d pay if you bought each alone. That makes Paragon a pretty darn good deal.)
What’s different?
Features and interface. Paragon has developed significantly since last year. It has some pretty looking tools and interfaces, although I don’t think they change much in a practical sense. It now comes with a pretty menu item which shows your drives and offers quick access repair/mounting/etc. If you don’t find that useful, you can turn it off.
Tuxera is pretty much unchanged.
The UI differences are sort of neither here nor there, although for my money, change is good. Minor point to Paragon for making an obvious effort to keep pace with Mojave.
Performance comparison
Long story short: Paragon pretty much smokes Tuxera. For spinning disks, the performance comparison is mostly unchanged – they’re both about the same, and performance varies ±10MB/s on the benchmark anyway depending on the direction of the wind. But the SSD performance delta has expanded from about 40% better for Paragon to more like 75% better for Paragon. Caveat emptor: this is moving from a 2.5GBit/s ExpressCard bottleneck on my old machine to the SSD’s internal flash bottleneck on the new one, but still – Paragon couldn’t quite saturate the ExpressCard on my old test, and now can just about saturate the SSD. These numbers are about what I get running a benchmark on a Windows machine with USB 3.0. Tuxera also improved over the old benchmark, as you can see, but not by nearly enough to even maintain that performance delta. Paragon is a clear and commanding winner here.
Disk | Driver | Connection | 2017 Read (MB/s) | 2017 Write (MB/s) | 2018 Read (MB/s) | 2018 Write (MB/s) | Winner? |
Internal SSD | (APFS) | NVMe | 2696.2 | 2646 | |||
SSD | Paragon | USB3 | 187.3 | 167.2 | 428 | 422 | Paragon (75%) |
SSD | Tuxera | USB3 | 133.1 | 119 | w/ caching: 242 w/o: 225 | w/ caching: 233 w/o: 105 | pretty reproduceable |
HDD | Paragon | USB3 | 106.8 | 104.9 | 90 | 92 | Tie |
HDD | Tuxera | USB3 | 104.7 | 103.6 | w/ caching: 97 w/o: 103 | w/ caching: 102 w/o: 80 | Both pretty variable. |
A note about caching
One thing I’m unclear on is how Paragon handles file system caching vs Tuxera. Tuxera offers the option to turn it off, at a performance penalty (that the benchmarks clearly show). Paragon offers no such option, so it’s unclear to me if the driver is doing caching or not. On Windows, I have write caching turned off by default for external devices since it improves FS resilience in sudden-disconnect scenarios, which can be tough to avoid especially with portables. This doesn’t seem to have a huge impact on performance, where it certainly does here. Oddly, Tuxera seems to be impacted even on read by having caching disabled, which I wouldn’t have expected to be noticeable in these tests.
Conclusion
Now that I’m much more performance-conscious in my driver choice, I’m much more inclined to switch to Paragon. For now, I’m going to run the trial and decide how I feel at the end of that. It seems likely I’ll buy the package deal for $50 with future upgrades, even though I don’t really need the other drivers. Plus, I already have a Tuxera license to cover other machines where I’m less performance-conscious.
Private | |
Industry | Software and embedded systems |
---|---|
Founded | Finland (2008) |
Headquarters | , |
Key people | Tuukka Ahoniemi, CEO Szabolcs Szakacsits, President and CTO |
Website | www.tuxera.com |
Tuxera Inc. develops and sells file systems software. Its most popular products are Tuxera NTFS and Tuxera exFAT, both available on a number of platforms including Linux, Android, QNX and macOS. Tuxera's customers include a number of consumer electronics manufacturers in mobile phones, tablets, TVs, set-top boxes, automotive infotainment and storage markets.[1] Tuxera NTFS for Mac provides read-write connectivity to Windows formatted hard drives for macOS.[2]
The company was founded in 2008 and is currently headquartered in Espoo, Finland. Tuxera's other offices are located in US, South Korea,[3], Japan, Germany, Taiwan and China.
History[edit]
The origin of the company dates back to the open-source NTFS development in the late 1990s. NTFS had been introduced in 1993 by Microsoft as the file system for Windows NT. At that time Anton Altaparmakov emerged as the lead developer and maintainer of the Linux NTFS kernel driver. Meanwhile, Szabolcs Szakacsits continued to lead a platform-independent project under the name NTFS-3G. In 2006, NTFS-3G became the first driver to gain full read and write support. Commercial activity started in 2007 and the company was founded next year. In 2009 the company signed agreements with Microsoft,[4] which was followed by global expansion and establishing the collaboration with chipset vendors and software platform companies.[5]
In February 2011 Tuxera joined the Linux Foundation,[6] which was an expected step as for many years Tuxera has contributed to the Linux kernel.
In July 2019 Tuxera acquired Datalight, [7] to strengthen its internal storage offering and expertise in flash memory and flash management software. Omnisphere.
Embedded products[edit]
Microsoft NTFS by Tuxera (formerly Tuxera NTFS)[edit]
Tuxera NTFS is a performance optimized, fail-safe, fully compatible NTFS file system driver. It ships for example in smart TVs, set-top boxes, smartphones, tablets, routers, NAS and other devices. It is available for Android and other Linux platforms, QNX, WinCESeries 40, Nucleus RTOS and VxWorks. Supported architectures are ARM architecture, MIPS architecture, PowerPC, SuperH and x86.
Microsoft exFAT by Tuxera (formerly Tuxera exFAT)[edit]
Tuxera exFAT technology is used for SDXC memory card support. Tuxera was the first independent vendor to receive legal access to exFAT and TexFAT specifications, source code and verification tools from Microsoft.[8] Tuxera exFAT can be found in automotive infotainment systems, Android phones and tablets from ASUS, Fujitsu, Panasonic, Pantech and others.[9]
Microsoft FAT by Tuxera (formerly Tuxera FAT)[edit]
Tuxera FAT software provides interoperability and support for storage types such as SD memory card, CF card, Memory Stick, SSD, HDD via USB, SATA, eSATA, MMC and others.[10] It is used by chipset and hardware manufacturers, and software and system integrators for full compliance with Microsoft patent licenses and GPL.
NTFS-3G[edit]
NTFS-3G is the original free-software 'community edition' driver used widely in Linux distributions, including Fedora, Ubuntu, and others. In April 12, 2011 it was announced that Ntfsprogs project was merged with NTFS-3G.[11]
VelocityFS by Tuxera (formerly Tuxera Flash File System)[edit]
Tuxera also develops and commercializes its own proprietary Flash file system. Due to its fail-safe technology it can be found for instance in vehicles and cars, integrated with the event data recorder to make sure the data recorded from sensors is consistent even in case of a crash.[12]
Tuxera FAT+[edit]
In 2017, Tuxera introduced FAT+[13], a file system implementation for Universal Flash Storage cards and removable storage that is compatible with FAT32 but without the file size limitation of 4 GiB. It is royalty free for UFS card host devices[14] and a standard recommended by the Universal Flash Storage Association[15].
Consumer products[edit]
AllConnect[edit]
AllConnect is a mobile app that allows to stream music, photos and videos from Android devices to DLNA receivers (smart TVs, set-top-boxes, wireless speakers, etc.). It was launched in November 12, 2013 under the name of Streambels.[16]
Tuxera NTFS for Mac[edit]
Tuxera NTFS for Mac allows macOS computers to read and write NTFS partitions. By default, macOS provides only read access to NTFS partitions. The latest stable version of the driver is 2016, released in September 2016.[17] With the introduction of System Integrity Protection (SIP) by Apple in OS X El Capitan, usage of third-party software in Disk Utility is no longer possible. As a workaround, Tuxera NTFS for Mac ships together with Tuxera Disk Manager[18] to facilitate the format and maintenance of NTFS volumes in macOS. Currently the software supports 13 languages: Arabic, Simplified and Traditional Chinese, English, French, German, Italian, Japanese, Korean, Portuguese, Russian, Spanish and Turkish.[19] The software supports 64-bit kernels, including OS X El Capitan.[20] It supports NTFS extended attributes and works with virtualization and encryption solutions including Parallels Desktop and VMware Fusion.
Exfat Vs Ntfs Sd Card
SD Memory Card Formatter[edit]
Tuxera developed the official formatting application for SecureDigital memory cards, which is available as a free download for Windows and macOS.[21]
See also[edit]
References[edit]
Exfat On Mac
- ^Tuxera Shows Example In Finding Your Niche
- ^https://appducate.com/2013/01/read-write-to-windows-ntfs-partition-on-mac/
- ^Tuxera Opens Office in Korea - Market Leader in File Systems Expands Service and Support Across Asia
- ^https://blogs.technet.com/b/port25/archive/2009/08/26/tuxera-signs-file-system-ip-agreement-with-microsoft.aspx
- ^Suomalaisfirman ohjelmisto löytyy uusista Bemareista ja Mersuista
- ^https://www.reuters.com/article/2011/02/08/idUS118124+08-Feb-2011+MW20110208 Tuxera Joins Linux Foundation (Reuters)
- ^https://nordic9.com/news/tuxera-acquired-datalight-from-us-news2062421531/ Tuxera acquired Datalight from US
- ^James Kendrick, Android, Linux get Large File Handling With Tuxera exFAT
- ^Jani Timonen, 'Kotimainen ohjelmistoyritys Tuxera on teknologiaraketti – kasvua yli 6000 prosenttia', Helsingin Sanomat, 14.07.2015. Retrieved 05.10.2015.
- ^Tuxera FAT by Tuxera Inc.
- ^NTFS-3G Merges With NTFSprogs, Plus New Version
- ^Kristen Hall-Geisler, The importance of black boxes in an autonomous automotive future, 'TechCrunch', 13.05.2016. Retrieved 15.05.2016.
- ^Tuxera FAT+ File System for Embedded Systems is Compatible with FAT32, Faster, and Supports Files up to 16TB
- ^Mikko Välimäki, Introducing FAT+: A royalty-free file system technology for removable UFS cards, Flash Memory Summit, 10.08.2017. Retrieved 11.01.2018.
- ^Universal Flash Storage Association, Tuxera introduces FAT+, a futureproof and interoperable file system technology for Removable Flash Storage
- ^Streambels App Brings AirPlay and DLNA to Android Phones and Tablets Supports Media Streaming to the Most Popular Smart Devices on the Market
- ^Tuxera NTFS for Mac Release History
- ^Tuxera Disk Manager works around El Capitan to format drives that work with Windows
- ^Tuxera NTFS for Mac 2012
- ^RoaringApps - application compatibility for Mac OS X El Capitan
- ^https://www.sdcard.org/downloads/formatter/